The Toiyabe Chapter of the Sierra Club celebrates its 50th anniversary this year, 2007.
Who were the Chapter founders, what did they do, and what were their
issues? What can we learn from them? In particular,
what were and are the critical factors for success of an environmental
organization? And, even more important, what are the key
personalities and essential roles of the individual participants?
Consider the founders of the Toiyabe Chapter fifty years ago and with
which individuals you most identify. This article examines the
founding and the first ten years of the Toiyabe Chapter. I have
tried to reconstruct the personalities involved, based on information
from several of the remaining participants.
TOP
The founders started from a nucleus of about 20 friends who loved the wild outdoors.
They socialized together for at least 2 years before petitioning to
found a Sierra Club in December, 1956. The Chapter was
founded in 1957. The founders had fun which included outdoor
outings, such as walks and short hikes in wild areas, snow shoeing,
rock climbing, lots of parties, and even cowboy poetry. There
were over 25 members of the early social group, including in
alphabetical order Nancy and Grace Borderwich, Jane Bowden*, Jeanne and
Gus Bundy, Elizabeth (chair 58-9) and Jack Crenshaw, Jane* and Bob*
Gaw, Victor Goodwin, Nancy* and Les (first chair, ‘57) Gould, Sam
(chair 60-61) and Edda Houghton, Carola Hutchinson* (chair, 64), Hal
Klieforth* (chair 66-7), Maya and Dick* Miller, Milla and Ken
Thompson, Irving Pressman, Olga and Jack Reifschneider, Joseph
Schubert, David Thompson (chair for part of 64 and 65) and his wife,
and Ed Worley. (The *indicate those individual still living.)
TOP
Who were these founders of the Chapter?
Most of them were in their 20s and 30s at the time. Starting from
A to G, Nancy and Grace Borderwich were sisters living in Carson
City. Grace was a school teacher and Nancy was an artist.
Nancy went on many outings with Don Bowers whom she later
married. Jeanne and Gus Bundy ran a guest ranch in the days when
people came to Nevada for 6 weeks in order to qualify for divorce
proceedings. Gus was a master photographer of wilderness,
including wild horses. His photographs are archived in the
University of Nevada, Reno library. (The Bundy’s are also the
parents of Tina Nappe, 2005-6 Toiyabe Chapter Chair.) Elizabeth
(‘Betty’) and Admiral Jack Crenshaw were somewhat older. He was a
retired Commandant at the Hawthorne Naval Ammunition Depot and manager
of the Whittell Estate at Lake Tahoe, including what is now known as
Thunderbird Lodge. She was the initiator and organizer of the
Chapter, starting in 1954, and wrote the petition for chapter status in
December, 1956. To quote Bob Gaw, “Betty was the true spark who
championed the concept of the chapter”. Jane and Bob Gaw were the
only two teachers in the elementary school at Zephyr Cove from
1954-1957. They were in their twenties and the social group
opened up a world of adventure. There are memories of Bob rock
climbing with Sam Houghton, a special dinner party given by the
Crenshaws in the caretaker’s quarters of the Whittell Estate, and of
their first exposure to cowboy poetry. Victor (‘Vic’) Goodwin, US
Forest Service Toiyabe District Ranger, was a “tough rough guy” to
quote Bob Gaw. Vic lived in a government-issue house in Carson
City that was also the ranger station in the 1950s. There were
many fun meetings in that ranger house. (There is now a tree at
the Carson City Railroad Museum that is named in Vic’s
honor.) Les Gould was a psychiatrist with a
substantial clinical practice; his wife Nancy led hikes.
TOP
The founders with last names from H to Z were equally diverse individuals.
Sam and Edda Houghton were very active participants. Sam was an
outdoorsman, the rock climbing was serious with ropes, belays,
etc. He was very concerned with water issues (which in those days
included Lake Tahoe). Sam Houghton wrote Trace of Desert Waters,
published in 1986. Carola Hutchinson lived in Carson City and was
a big outings leader, and later did the entire Pacific Crest Trail
after age 60. Hal Klieforth was a meteorologist at the Desert
Research Institute in Reno and loved his job of going into the
mountains in winter to monitor the amount of snowfall. Maya
Miller was an extremely warm and socially conscious person who was very
active in politics to improve the conditions of life, and even ran for
US Senate. Her husband Dick Miller was an
ichthyologist. Olga Reifschneider loved nature. She
had passion, and is remembered for once having fits about the members’
cars damaging the plants on one of the outings, setting a precedent for
recognition of the long term impact of vehicles in natural
areas. Joseph Schubert, was Nevada State Librarian.
David Thompson was a practicing MD who established the first Chapter
classes in wilderness first aid. Ed Worley, is described by Marge
Sill as, “The best man she ever knew, [who] lived his religion, [which
was] respect for the earth”.
TOP
The Chapter was established in 1957 with 83 members and quickly grew.
Several of the early members had very positive experiences with the
Sierra Club in California, which provided the inspiration for joining
the national organization. Five years later, in 1962, there were
193 Toiyabe members, and 551 by the tenth anniversary. There were
monthly meetings and outings open to all.
TOP
Fun continued.
A lot of the fun centered around Lake Tahoe. There were
outings at the Lake, snow shoeing a Spooner Lake, and hikes to Marlette
Lake. In the first ten years, outings extended to the White
Mountains east of the Sierra Nevada and to Red Rock Canyon in southern
Nevada. “The biggest thing then was that people were friends and
enjoyed each other” to quote Marge Sill. Some of these
individuals felt truly out of place upon arrival in Nevada and found
kindred spirits within the Chapter. One person reminds the reader
that “Nevada was the ‘Mississippi of the West’, a state with low
education levels, low incomes, low self esteem, low ambitions for the
state, and racist attitudes”. The state population in1957 was
249,500, with approximately 100,000 people living in Las Vegas.
TOP
Several
key members in the first 10 years of the Chapter arrived in Nevada
after the founding of the Chapter. Marge* and Dick (chair 62-63)
Sill arrived in 1959. Marge was a math teacher in Sparks
High School, and soon became the prolific and knowledgeable author for
the Toiyabe Tattler, the Chapter newsletter, a role she continues
today. Dick was a physicist at the University of Nevada, Reno,
and a strong leader for legislation for environmental protection.
TOP
What were the issues of this young environmental group?
An early issue was Lake Tahoe, its protection and the foundation of the
Nevada State Park at Lake Tahoe. Publicizing the
environmental issues was essential, the Toiyabe “Tattler” was the
Chapter newsletter, which had articles contributed by numerous
members. The Chapter strongly supported the federal 1964
Wilderness Bill. The Jarbidge became Nevada’s first
wilderness because it was the only administrative US Forest Service
wilderness study area in Nevada in 1964. Upon passage of the 1964
Wilderness Bill, all the previous administrative areas throughout the
country received wilderness status. Many members of the Chapter
immediately set out to identify, enjoy and advocate wilderness and park
status for other remarkable areas throughout the Great Basin.
TOP
What were the key roles of the individual participants?
There were so many initiators of outings, ideas and dreams that they
cannot be named today. There was an organizer, Jane Bowden, who
kept the lists of telephone numbers, addresses, meeting places, times,
etc. There were chairs, people who interacted with the national
Sierra Club and ensured that the Chapter meetings ran
productively. There were strong leaders, including Dick
Sill. There can be no question that Marge Sill, contributor to
the “Toiyabe Tattler” now named the “Toiyabe Trails” has been a
respected publicist for 48 years. There were outstanding
photographers, Gus Bundy and Irving Pressman, whose pictures were more
valuable than words. There were strategists, people who refined
and focused issues, including Maya Miller and Sam Houghton. Maya
was a dedicated Democrat; Sam a confirmed Republican. Each was
able to make critical personal connections for political support of
state and federal legislative issues. There were emergency
financiers; for example, the publication costs of the “Tattler” would
exceed the budget and Sam Houghton, Dick Sill, and perhaps Maya Miller
reached into their pockets to keep the Chapter solvent. There
were social moderators, the kind people who can get warring believers
to enjoy each other’s company, notably Betty Crenshaw and Hal
Klieforth. And of utmost importance, there were happy members of
the Chapter, who joined and remained in the Chapter, participated in
outings, and supported Chapter issues.
TOP
In closing, take a look at yourself.
Every dues-paying member counts behind the testimony and advocacy of
Chapter representatives on environmental issues. Take the torch
from the past, start having more fun. More information about the
early Toiyabe Chapter can be found at
htttp://nevada.sierraclub.org/halfcentury. Special thanks
for this article go to Bob Gaw, Hall Klieforth and Marge Sill.
Please contact Dorothy Hudig at
dhudig@medicine.nevada.edu or (775)
323-4835 with additional information and corrections for this 1-23-07
version, which will be used to update the website version.
TOP